John Cusack and Sabbath as Submission to Finitude

In the movie High Fidelity, John Cusack’s character reflects upon his life and recognizes he suffers from a certain kind of neurosis – one which assumes at the youthful age of 25 that his present singleness is inevitably unending. I, like many others, tend to assume the same thing about theology. Present ignorance somehow leads to the belief that I must give myself to an onslaught of neurotic reading habits to somehow make up for lost time – lest I be “single” (read ignorant) forever. This disposition is enslaved to a subconscious belief that there is a hidden wormhole in the fabric of the creature-Creator distinction which I can access through sheer fortitude, and, in a moment always eluding my grasp, will one day deliver me to an infinite knowledge of all things.

But, in the words of the writer to the Hebrews, there is a sabbath rest for the people of God. Sabbath, for those of us who suffer from this kind of theological anxiety, is a submission to finitude – a time to rest in our calling as broken witnesses and to put down our strategies to undo our creatureliness. It is a sacrifice of our desire for transcendence and an acceptance of the real messy, broken finitude of our existence. This, I suggest, should be spurred on by our relation to the ecclesial community in which we partake as theologians – feeling the weight of the mundane as we secretly wish to disappear to our office and read something interesting (as opposed to, to use Eugene Peterson’s example, talk to some lady about her cat).

In a moment of reflection, Cusack’s character muses about his past relationships, and notes that he always had one foot out the door to consider other (and presumably better), options, which he suggests, is suicide in tiny increments. In a similar way, and with the same incremental death, a failure to heed the rest of Sabbath as a theologian is the attempt to build a Tower of Babel from the stacks of books we so proudly display, the lines on our C.V. we are so excited to add, and the growing obscurity of our interests which we relish to expand like the borders of Jabez’s dominion.

Sabbath rest is a practical corollary to the Creator-creature distinction, where creatures submit to their Creator through a wholesale acceptance of creatureliness. Sabbath rest, therefore, as a call to embrace our creatureliness, follows the contours of created reality through an imitatio Dei. It is being like God as a creature, rather than, as the temptation of Eden reveals, being like God as God. The embrace of the fruit of Eden is the continual rejection of creatureliness which fuels much theological endeavour, not the least of which is the temptation to cure our theological ineptitudes and anxieties through brute force and will. It is the theologian who embraces their anthropological weakness who will know, following Paul, God’s theological strength. The Sabbath rest for the theologian is submitting to wisdom for the renewal of one’s mind along the contours of God’s self-revelation in Christ, whereby we come to know dependence in the very act of mortifying independence.

This will mean, to pick back up on Eugene Peterson, that we come to practice speaking the “words of the kingdom” in everyday conversations with old women about their cats, with widows about their t.v. shows and with the youth about their favorite superheroes. Sabbath rest for the theologian, in part, will be a reintergration into the community where normal people live and move and have their being – as a reminder that this is our community and our life – which is, in reality, more real than the academic world which seems to have more to offer.

6 thoughts on “John Cusack and Sabbath as Submission to Finitude

  1. Transcendence, our conventional/priestly/ministerial “heaven,” is much, much simpler than people think. It really is monochromatic: white angels with white harps, in white clouds. Or: as simple as Patience, and Perspective; knowing that “all things,” troubling as they might seem over the short term, can “work out” for the good, longer term, in philosophicality, in perspective. With acceptance – and a little of our own guidance?

    So you might have achieved transcendence without noticing it. Or overlooked or rejected it, as being too simple. You can simply say “the ONE,” or say “Ohhmmmmmmm,” or “Onnneeeee,” and already be halfway there, just with one Word.

    What we are interested here and now, is beyond Transcendence. What we are interested in, is taking the entire “blooming, buzzing confusion” of concrete, physical, material life, on earth, in all its Jon-Edwards-era Baroque un-linearity… and ordering it slightly; giving it perspective. While simultaneously honoring all its full complexity; including our “creature-liness.”

  2. First, kudos for commenting on a great movie.

    Second, I love the connection between theological self-aggrandizement and the need for Sabbath renewal as a reminder that we’re not all that. As I was reading it, I was reminded of Barth’s consistent emphasis on prayer as the proper posture for the Christian theologian. It would seem that we need to be constantly bombarded by messages about our creatureliness and dependence, as well as God’s grace and glory, if we’re to protect ourselves from our self-abusive pursuit of things we can’t (and shouldn’t) handle.

    • Marc, yes, that is a great movie (I’m a bit of a Cusack fan). I have been impacted by Barth’s emphasis on prayer, and think that is right. The posture of prayer seems to be the only fitting posture for pilgrim theology.

  3. Pingback: On the importance of taking theological sabbaths « scientia et sapientia

  4. Pingback: links for 2010-07-19 | The 'K' is not silent

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s